The Dallas Cowboys find themselves in turbulent waters midway through the 2024 season. Sitting at 3-4, the team is struggling to meet its usual high expectations after three straight 12-win seasons under head coach Mike McCarthy. With McCarthy on the final year of his contract, discussions are heating up about potential coaching replacements if Dallas decides to go a new route.
Owner Jerry Jones has made it clear he’s not considering a midseason coaching change. But with each loss, fans and pundits are dreaming up replacements that could shake up the Dallas sideline. Here are seven out-of-the-box candidates for head coach—some serious, others purely for fun—that could bring a fresh twist to Cowboys Nation.
1. Jerry Jones
Who better to take the reins than the man who’s been calling the shots since 1989? As one of the most hands-on owners in the NFL, Jones has certainly shaped the Cowboys’ identity, both on and off the field.
While it’s highly unlikely we’ll see Jerry on the sidelines, imagining him in the role sparks plenty of debate. After all, Jones is already one of the most visible faces of the Cowboys, so why not take it one step further?
2. Deion Sanders
A former Cowboy himself, Deion Sanders has made waves as a charismatic and bold college coach. Since taking over at the University of Colorado, Sanders has redefined player recruitment and demonstrated a unique ability to energize a team.
Though he’s expressed little interest in an NFL coaching role, Sanders’ combination of charisma and coaching savvy would certainly turn heads in Dallas. His player-first approach and knack for motivating could bring an undeniable spark to a Cowboys franchise in need of fresh energy.
3. Tony Romo
Tony Romo’s football IQ and charisma have shined in his transition to the broadcast booth, where he’s quickly become a fan favorite. Many wonder if Romo’s deep understanding of the game could translate to coaching, and Dallas could be a perfect fit.
While Romo seems content as a broadcaster, his knowledge and connection to the franchise make him an intriguing choice for head coach. Bringing Romo on board would give the Cowboys an analytical edge, even if it’s a long shot.
4. Pete Carroll
Known for his energetic, player-centered coaching style, Pete Carroll has long been a successful head coach with the Seattle Seahawks. At 73, Carroll may be nearing the end of his NFL career, but his proven track record and ability to build winning cultures could be just what Dallas needs.
Jerry Jones has shown an affinity for seasoned coaches in the past, and Carroll’s experience might provide a stabilizing influence. However, his age and the Seahawks’ recent struggles could make this a temporary solution.
5. Nick Saban
Widely regarded as one of college football’s all-time greats, Nick Saban is no stranger to the NFL. His previous stint with the Miami Dolphins wasn’t as successful, but his record-breaking college coaching career suggests he could bring a lot to the table.
Known for his meticulous attention to detail and relentless pursuit of excellence, Saban would bring a rigorous approach to the Cowboys. With Dallas’ resources and fanbase, he might just be tempted to make one more NFL run.
6. Bill Belichick
The name Bill Belichick is synonymous with success, having led the New England Patriots to multiple Super Bowl titles. However, the disciplined, no-nonsense approach that has defined Belichick’s career could be a tough match with Jerry Jones’ hands-on style.
While there’s speculation that Jones might reach out if McCarthy’s tenure ends, the partnership would only work if Jones allows Belichick full control—something Cowboys fans know may not be in Jones’ nature.
7. Skip Bayless
Here’s one for the dreamers: sports commentator Skip Bayless. His outspoken personality and intense knowledge of the Cowboys could make for an electrifying choice—if not for his complete lack of NFL coaching experience.
Bayless has been an ardent Cowboys fan, and his love for the team is evident in his passionate commentary. Although it’s highly unlikely, and perhaps impossible, to see Bayless on the sideline, it’s a pick that would bring the Cowboys plenty of media attention.
Conclusion
From Jerry Jones to Skip Bayless, these coaching options highlight just how much Dallas fans crave a fresh direction. While each candidate brings their own set of skills and quirks, Jerry Jones will ultimately decide the team’s future direction. Cowboys fans can only speculate for now, but these choices show that a surprising twist could be just what Dallas needs to shake things up. Whether Dallas goes for an established figure or a bold newcomer, one thing is certain: change is in the air in Big D.
