Mike McCarthy entered this season with an uncertain future. The Dallas Cowboys head coach was in the final year of his contract, and owner Jerry Jones made it clear: McCarthy’s job was on the line. For anyone familiar with Jones, the parallels to Jason Garrett’s final season in 2019 were impossible to ignore.
But McCarthy’s situation has been far more challenging. Injuries have plagued the roster, leaving gaps in depth and talent. The veteran coach has faced the season with a depleted offensive line, an aging Ezekiel Elliott, and a lackluster receiver group beyond CeeDee Lamb. While McCarthy is not without fault—clock management and discipline remain consistent criticisms—he is a proven winner.
MORE: Cowboys star named potential free agent signee for Dan Quinn, Commanders
McCarthy boasts a 45-31 record in Dallas, including a dominant 36-15 run between 2021 and 2023 when Dak Prescott was healthy. His career record, 170-108-2, places him among the NFL’s most successful active coaches, with a 61.1% winning percentage.
Man, the human side of you really makes you feel for McCarthy here leaving AT&T last night. He’s at the fight and he sees Irvin talking to Jerry on the big screen about how he’s going to get in his ear about Deion and JJ’s smiling about it. Guy is done. pic.twitter.com/PvKbalWi06
— Windy City Cowboys fan ✭ (@MrSoprano21) November 17, 2024
Yet, McCarthy seems set up to fail. Jones has continually undermined any hope for a second act of redemption. A telling moment occurred during the recent Mike Tyson-Jake Paul fight at AT&T Stadium. A video surfaced showing McCarthy leaving the venue, seemingly isolated, while Jones was in front of cameras discussing Deion Sanders as a potential head coaching candidate for 2025.
The message was clear: McCarthy is expendable. The lack of public support from Jones, combined with a lackluster roster, has stripped McCarthy of the tools necessary to succeed. Even his strong win-loss record and playoff appearances haven’t shifted the narrative in his favor.
McCarthy once hoped Dallas would be his chance to rebuild his reputation after his tenure in Green Bay ended on a sour note. Instead, he faces criticism and a looming sense of inevitability that his time in Dallas is nearing its end. If McCarthy’s story in Dallas ends this year, the blame may lie less with his coaching and more with Jones’ inability to give him the proper support.
In a season of mounting losses and constant speculation, the Cowboys’ head coach has been fighting an uphill battle—a battle he may never have been meant to win.
