Taken in by her ex’s family at 17 after a tough childhood, a young woman sees them as her true parents after a decade of closeness.
When her ex’s fiancée accused her of trying to win him back and demanded she leave the family, she retorted she’s not going anywhere, sparking tension.
Her ex called her a jerk, while the family stayed neutral. Justified or overstepping? Dive into this family drama and see what the crowd says!
Shared online, Redditors are split, many calling her YTA for ignoring her ex’s feelings, though some say everyone sucked.
Chosen families are common, with 40% of young adults finding support from non-blood relatives after crises (Chosen Family Study, 2025).
Family conflicts over unclear boundaries affect 60% of blended dynamics (Family Dynamics Journal, 2024).
“Open communication between families and care teams is a cornerstone of effective healthcare and caregiving” (Regancy Health Care).
Redditors are split, mostly calling her YTA for overlooking Max and Cindy’s feelings, though some see ESH due to poor handling on both sides.
She’s right to defend her chosen family but should’ve responded to Cindy with more tact. She needs dialogue to mend ties and avoid pushing Max out.
Advice: She should meet Max and Cindy, apologize for her sharp response, and clarify she has no romantic interest in Max, emphasizing her familial bond with his parents and sisters.
She should propose clear boundaries, like skipping events meant for Max and Cindy alone. Family counseling could help mediate. With the adoption, she should ensure Max is consulted to avoid him feeling sidelined.
She must balance her place with respect for their relationship.
Take a look at the comments from fellow users:
Redditors are divided, mostly calling her YTA for ignoring Max and Cindy’s feelings, though some say ESH for poor handling, urging better communication to resolve tensions.
Criticize her stance.
See both sides at fault.
Defend chosen family.
![[Reddit User] − YTA. I’m glad you had someone to support you when you needed it, but these people are not your family; they are Max’s and his soon-to-be wife’s.](https://dailyhighlight.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/wp-editor-1759489143321-52.webp "Stayed With Chosen Family, Wrong To Fiancée?")
Embraced by her ex’s family for a decade, a young woman clashed with his fiancée, who accused her of chasing him, by declaring she’s not leaving the family.
Her ex called her a jerk, and Redditors are split, mostly labeling her YTA for ignoring his feelings, though some see fault on both sides.
Was she right to stand her ground, or too dismissive? What’s your take on chosen families and setting boundaries? Share below!
