Daily Highlight
  • MOVIE
  • TV
  • CELEB
  • ENTERTAINMENT
  • MCU
  • DISNEY
  • About US
Daily Highlight
No Result
View All Result

Law Firm Tried To Trick A Lawyer Into Doing Free Work, So He Sued Them Using Their Own Tactics And Got Paid

by Annie Nguyen
November 12, 2025
in Social Issues

Job interviews can reveal more about a company than a candidate, especially when the process starts feeling less like an evaluation and more like an extraction. In fields built on precision and ethics, any hint of corner-cutting during hiring raises immediate alarms for those who know the terrain.

The original poster, a lawyer specializing in discovery disputes, spotted a listing that already smelled off due to the firm’s typical caseload. What began as a routine application quickly morphed into a request for unpaid work on a live legal issue. Scroll down to see how the poster turned the tables and what the community thought of the firm’s tactics.

A savvy lawyer spots a job ad for a discovery expert role at a local firm, but the interview twists into a sneaky request for unpaid research on an active case

Law Firm Tried To Trick A Lawyer Into Doing Free Work, So He Sued Them Using Their Own Tactics And Got Paid
Not the actual photo

Want me to work for my 'interview'? Will do!?

I mostly work in a niche-ish area of law called discovery. Basically when someone starts a legal proceeding

each party gets to ask other parties for certain documents relevant to the case.

Sometimes parties refuse to produce certain documents because of reasons like attorney-client privilege.

I argue why my clients' documents are properly withheld or the other sides' documents are improperly withheld.

One day I see a job board post from a local law firm looking for a research and writing position

with required experience in discovery disputes. This raises a red flag for two reasons.

First, local law firms normally do not need to hire full time research and writing people

because more than 95% of that firms cases are very similar. For instance a personal injury firm normally only handles personal injury cases,

so keeping a full time researcher is not worthwhile when all your cases are basically the same.

When these local firms need something researched they either just do it themselves or pay someone else for a few hours of work.

Second, this local firm hired a friend of mine by telling them "start here, work hard,

and move up to senior associate in a few years" before promptly letting them go after a few busy months.

I go ahead and send my resume over and get scheduled for an interview pretty quickly.

During the interview I gave them a fairly high salary ask which they agreed to almost instantly.

Then the partner hits me with the following. Partner: "We ask all candidates to provide a writing sample before the final interview."

Me: "Sure thing. I thought I attached one to the application, but let me grab my phone and double check."

P: "Oh not that writing sample, that is too generic for evaluation. Here is a legal question that we want you to research."

M: "I see. More than happy to do that at an hourly rate."

P: "It should be fairly quick work. No other candidate has asked us for writing-sample-compensation,

and this makes it seem like you won't be a team player. If you aren't interested in the position just tell us."

M: "Let me think about it."

So I go home and search a couple of local court dockets and wouldn't you know it

this firm is involved in a case with a hearing set on exactly the discovery question

they want me to produce a free 'writing sample' on.

I send an email back saying sure thing I will make the writing sample,

as long as it guarantees consideration for the research and writing position. They say yes.

I write a fantastic memo and send it in.

A few weeks go by and I email asking for an update on the final interview.

No response. Then I check that court docket and wouldn't you know it

they straight up copy pasted parts of my memo in the response.

I send a demand letter for payment plus fees. No response. I file a lawsuit for fraud.

Oh baby THEN I got a response. A frothy, salty response. Frothaltly.

I got called some names. They went on and on about how I was going to lose

AND after I lost how they were going to counter sue me.

I said "sounds good, can't wait to lose. I guess you did hire a full time research and writing attorney.

I mean, it would be like baby-town frolics easy to win if you never hired for that position.

Actually, it would be even easier if you never even had a final interview for the spot.

I'm sure you aren't that dumb though." Got the check 30 days later.

Revenge stories often begin with something deeply human, the feeling of being exploited. For many professionals, few things sting more than realizing their hard work was used without acknowledgment or pay. In this story, the lawyer’s “writing sample” was never about proving skill; it was about trust.

The firm’s deceit, disguising unpaid labor as part of an interview, struck at a core emotional truth: the need for fairness. Both sides acted from recognizable emotions. The lawyer sought respect for his expertise; the firm, desperate for free help, masked greed as opportunity.

From a psychological perspective, OP’s reaction wasn’t just about money, it was about reclaiming agency. According to research on moral injury, people experience deep distress when their integrity is violated in professional settings.

Revenge, then, becomes a form of restoring balance, a way to reassert control when power has been taken away. The OP’s decision to sue wasn’t purely punitive; it was restorative, a declaration that expertise has value and deception carries consequences.

Many might view this story as simple karmic justice, but there’s a deeper layer worth exploring. The OP’s calm, strategic response contrasts sharply with the emotional manipulation used by the firm.

While anger could have led to impulsive retaliation, he chose a lawful route, transforming rage into reason. In that sense, this act of “revenge” wasn’t vengeance at all, but a lesson in professional boundaries.

Psychologist Dr. Frederic Luskin, director of the Stanford Forgiveness Project, notes that revenge feels satisfying because it temporarily restores a sense of justice, but true empowerment comes from responding with integrity.

The lawyer’s approach embodies that principle. His response didn’t perpetuate harm; it reaffirmed fairness through accountability.

Ultimately, this story speaks to every professional who’s been undervalued or exploited. Revenge may feel sweet, but dignity tastes better.

Here’s what the community had to contribute:

These Redditors cheered the lawyer’s savvy takedown of the firm’s illegal trickery and bluster

Haywoodjablowme1029 − I don't understand how LAWYERS think that they could trick another LAWYER by BREAKING THE LAW.

I mean, I know idiots can become lawyers, but damn.

Plannerer − That is shady as hell. I can imagine some people would be intimidated by the bluster,

but another lawyer would be used to pressing 'hold' on the panic button and thinking through it.

What are the chances that the smoke and mirrors will cut it then? Pure lunacy.

The-Sidequester − "Never deal with a devil, they're in the details and you're not."

That part about "not being a team player" is rich. My guess is that they were the kids in school

who let the other people in their group do the project and got the grade for nothing.

I love everything about this post. Bravo sir.

These users backed spotting and refusing free work traps, sharing similar exploitation stories

Im_your_life − I like your style. The only interview I had that asked me to do some work

actually presented me with a long closed case, and the work they asked for was simply to determine

if I actually knew the matter or if I claimed I knew it well but actually had to spend hours

researching just to be able to argue simple points about it. It didn't take me more than a page to complete it.

Your story is the legal version of "enter this contest, submit your idea of our logo!

We will use the best one and the winner will get a lollipop!"

kumama07 − This was a great read! People over at r/antiwork often talk about "employers"

requesting free work, i.e. trial days, writing samples, et cetera, before hiring. It's definitely a trap when they ask for these things.

DaoNayt − P: "Oh not that writing sample, that is too generic for evaluation. Here is a legal question that we want you to research."

M: "I see. More than happy to do that at an hourly rate."

This right here is how you reply every time a business asks you to do real work as a test for employment.

Businesses will absolutely exploit applicants like this to get what is basically a large pool of free labor.

bg-j38 − Totally different industry but I work in telecom. I got referred by a friend of mine

to a very large and well known company that was looking to build a call center.

I spent some time talking with the director over there who was looking to find someone to run that project for them.

She said OK before we bring you in for in person interviews, we have a writing assignment that we want you to do.

Not unheard of for this type of project so I said OK send it over.

She sends over this 10 page packet of questions that were basically like come up with a full project plan

and implementation guidelines for building out a massive call center. This is stuff that I'd put at least 40 hours

of work into just a preliminary analysis. Basically asking for a ton of free work

that at contractor prices would be hundreds of dollars an hour. I wrote back that I didn't think I was a good fit

but thanks for the consideration. I do wonder if they ever found a sucker to write that for them for free.

These commenters praised the humor, style, and historical parallels in the revenge win

Own-Cupcake7586 − "Baby-town frolics easy." Priceless, lol.

BigRiverHome − That is freakin' hilarious! And it isn't like you even have to go to the trouble

of hiring an attorney to represent you. Obviously, you may if you're not a litigator

and depending on how challenging it would be, but you don't HAVE to hire one.

ceebs87 − I love the ever so lawery disclaimer at the beginning! And your whole post was both fun and informative.

FoolishStone − This reminds me of a story from one of William Shatner's memoirs.

Gene Roddenberry came up with the concept of a TV series about a starship with relatable human characters

encountering other civilizations, as a sort of antidote to the very campy "sci fi" movies of the 50's and early 60's,

featuring radiation-enhanced monsters and aliens in gorilla suits.

He shopped the idea around various studios. Irwin Allen asked him to come in for a pitch meeting,

and showed a great deal of interest. They kept him there for hours explaining his concept,

especially his "similar Earths" theory, that evolution would follow similar paths on other planets,

resulting in civilizations resembling our own.

The practical upshot would be that the producer could save money using ordinary costumes and sets,

rather than breaking the budget every week on ever more impressive aliens.

Irwin Allen thanked him for his time and said they would get back to him. They never did.

However, as you have no doubt guessed, a new series premiered embracing many of his concepts,

named, of course, Lost In Space! Shortly after that, DesiLu picked up his ideas, and Star Trek was born.

This Reddit gem wraps with a lawyer outwitting a firm’s greed, turning a scam into a swift paycheck and a lesson in boundaries. It spotlights how pros protect their worth amid job market games. Do you think demanding pay upfront kills interview vibes, or is it smart self-defense? Ever turn a shady gig into gold? Drop your stories and hot takes below, let’s spill!

Annie Nguyen

Annie Nguyen

Hi, I'm Annie Nguyen. I'm a freelance writer and editor for Daily Highlight with experience across lifestyle, wellness, and personal growth publications. Living in San Francisco gives me endless inspiration, from cozy coffee shop corners to weekend hikes along the coast. Thanks for reading!

Related Posts

Dad Wanted the Cheapest Glasses for His Daughter – Aunt Gave Her Two Pairs and Contacts Instead
Social Issues

Dad Wanted the Cheapest Glasses for His Daughter – Aunt Gave Her Two Pairs and Contacts Instead

2 months ago
Man Making Three Times More Calls His Fiancée A Gold Digger When She Won’t Go 50/50
Social Issues

Man Making Three Times More Calls His Fiancée A Gold Digger When She Won’t Go 50/50

3 months ago
Wife Accuses Husband Of Taking Son And Best Friend Trick-Or-Treating In Matching Costumes Without Her
Social Issues

Wife Accuses Husband Of Taking Son And Best Friend Trick-Or-Treating In Matching Costumes Without Her

4 months ago
Abusive Ex Demands Unsupervised Visits After Anger Management Therapy Graduation, Mom Says No
Social Issues

Abusive Ex Demands Unsupervised Visits After Anger Management Therapy Graduation, Mom Says No

2 months ago
Woman Tells Aunt to Move If She Can’t Handle Her Breastfeeding Her 11-Month-Old – Now Family Is Upse
Social Issues

Woman Tells Aunt to Move If She Can’t Handle Her Breastfeeding Her 11-Month-Old – Now Family Is Upse

2 months ago
Daughter Excludes New Girl From Party, Mom Defends Her Decision to Other Parents
Social Issues

Daughter Excludes New Girl From Party, Mom Defends Her Decision to Other Parents

4 weeks ago

TRENDING

This Employee Discovered Their Lazy Coworker Earns $1,200 More
Social Issues

This Employee Discovered Their Lazy Coworker Earns $1,200 More

by Sunny Nguyen
July 21, 2025
0

...

Read more
She Refused to Make “Sisterhood Vows” to Her Stepsister – Now Everyone’s Calling Her Heartless
Social Issues

She Refused to Make “Sisterhood Vows” to Her Stepsister – Now Everyone’s Calling Her Heartless

by Sunny Nguyen
August 29, 2025
0

...

Read more
Company Refused To Reimburse A Cheap Train Ticket Without A Receipt, Dad Makes Them Pay For A $200 Taxi Instead
Social Issues

Company Refused To Reimburse A Cheap Train Ticket Without A Receipt, Dad Makes Them Pay For A $200 Taxi Instead

by Annie Nguyen
November 3, 2025
0

...

Read more
Is "The Land Before Time" Remake Really Happening? Fact Checked
DISNEY

Is “The Land Before Time” Remake Really Happening? Fact Checked

by Jeffrey Stone
April 17, 2024
0

...

Read more
‘Yellowstone’ Season 4 Is Finally Released On Peacock
ENTERTAINMENT

‘Yellowstone’ Season 4 Is Finally Released On Peacock

by Anna Martinez
April 25, 2024
0

...

Read more




Daily Highlight

© 2024 DAILYHIGHLIGHT.COM

Navigate Site

  • About US
  • Contact US
  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy
  • DMCA
  • Cookie Policy
  • ADVERTISING POLICY
  • Corrections Policy
  • SYNDICATION
  • Editorial Policy
  • Ethics Policy
  • Fact Checking Policy
  • Sitemap

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • MOVIE
  • TV
  • CELEB
  • ENTERTAINMENT
  • MCU
  • DISNEY
  • About US

© 2024 DAILYHIGHLIGHT.COM