A woman, deep in wedding plans, stirred drama by pushing their fiancé for a paternity test for his five-year-old daughter, Chloe, citing his ex’s infidelity. Footing half of Chloe’s upbringing costs, they crave clarity before vows, turning love’s glow into a tense standoff.
Reddit’s AITA erupted with spicy takes on loyalty versus truth, as the fiancé, steadfastly raising Chloe despite her mom’s flaky presence, faces doubt. This saga of devotion and DNA questions runs deeper than a soap opera twist, splitting hearts and opinions.
Woman wants her fiancé to get a paternity test for his daughter, for feat that they might not be related.
The Redditor probably wants a fresh start with her fiancé, hence the wish to have Chloe out of the picture as her mom. But she has her point for wanting her partner to get a paternity test, as there is a possibility that the child is the product of an affair. Let’s break it down.
She wants certainty about Chloe’s biology before committing to a lifetime of shared finances and parenting. On one hand, it’s practical: raising a child costs an average of $310,605 from birth to age 18, per a 2022 USDA report. Knowing the stakes feels reasonable.
On the flip side, the fiancé’s bond with Chloe, biological or not, is the heartbeat of this story. Pushing for a test risks shattering that connection, especially since he’s been her rock for five years.
The Redditor’s doubt stems from the ex’s infidelity, a wound that lingers like a bad aftertaste. Yet, the fiancé’s choice to raise Chloe, despite the uncertainty, screams devotion louder than any DNA test could. Reddit users called it: questioning paternity now feels like questioning his fatherhood.
Dr. Kristin Anderson Moore noted in “Marriage and the Family”: “…family structure matters for children, and the family structure that helps children the most is the family headed by married, biological parents.”
This applies here: Chloe’s stability hinges on her dad’s unwavering love, not a lab result. Forcing the issue could destabilize that bond, leaving emotional scars.
Zooming out, this saga taps into a broader issue: navigating blended families. About 40% of marriages in the U.S. involve stepchildren or complex family dynamics, according to Pew Research Center.
The Redditor’s hesitation reflects a common fear: committing to a role without full clarity. But love isn’t a spreadsheet. It’s messy, but it’s human. A neutral approach? Have an open chat with the fiancé about fears and finances without demanding a test. It’s about trust, not truth.
Check out how the community responded:
Some believe pushing for a paternity test is insensitive and prioritizes personal concerns over the fiancé’s bond with his daughter.
![[Reddit User] − YTA. Since:](https://dailyhighlight.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/wp-editor-1761529541698-4.webp "Fiancée Demands Paternity Test For Partner’s Daughter, Upon His Ex's Affair’s Lasting Echoes")
Others argue that biological paternity is irrelevant since the fiancé has chosen to be the child’s father.
![[Reddit User] − YTA, big time. She's his daughter, biological or not. He has chosen to take primary custody of her and has been her dad for five years.](https://dailyhighlight.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/wp-editor-1761529437550-3.webp "Fiancée Demands Paternity Test For Partner’s Daughter, Upon His Ex's Affair’s Lasting Echoes")
Some view the push for a paternity test as an attempt to disrupt the father-daughter relationship.
This Redditor’s paternity test dilemma is a rollercoaster of heart and hard truths.
Is it fair to demand proof when love’s already written the story? Or is clarity a must when dollars and devotion are on the line?
The fiancé’s bond with Chloe shines brighter than any test result, but the Redditor’s need for certainty is relatable.
Would you push for the truth, risking a family fracture, or let love lead the way? Share your hot takes!
