Wife Files For Divorce After Husband Wants Both Her And His Girlfriend

Love can often feel like a game of second chances. But how many is too many when betrayal becomes a pattern? For one woman, it wasn’t just the infidelity that broke her trust, it was the fact that her husband wasn’t even willing to make a choice between her and the other woman.

After years of loyalty and sacrifice, including raising his children from a previous relationship, she found herself once again on the receiving end of a shocking revelation: her husband was still pursuing someone else, despite claiming to want to work things out.

With her heart breaking and her patience thinning, she was faced with the toughest decision of her life: stay in a marriage that was built on broken promises, or finally say goodbye.

Scroll down to see why this story has sparked intense debate about boundaries, respect, and what it really means to forgive.

A woman divorces her husband after discovering his infidelity and his request to add another woman to their marriage

In this situation, the emotional core isn’t simply about a betrayal of trust, it’s about how deep that betrayal runs and how it forces a reevaluation of what’s healthy in a relationship.

The OP’s husband didn’t just cheat once; he maintained an affair, lied about it, and then pushed for a polyamorous relationship after years of presenting himself as a loving, monogamous partner.

This decision wasn’t just a bad choice, it was a pattern of repeated emotional neglect and disregard for the OP’s boundaries and feelings.

The betrayal here wasn’t only about physical infidelity but also about emotional manipulation: asking the OP to accept both him and his lover after he had broken the trust in their marriage.

Infidelity is one of the most damaging betrayals in a relationship, often leading to profound emotional consequences, including feelings of insecurity, sadness, and anger.

Research published in Psychology Today explains that the pain from infidelity isn’t just a passing disappointment; it’s a fundamental breach of trust, and that betrayal can lead to significant emotional distress.

For the OP, her anger and emotional distress aren’t just about the affair itself, they’re also about how her husband’s actions made her feel small, unimportant, and disregarded. It wasn’t just one betrayal but the consistent betrayal of her feelings and the false hope that he would change.

Research on infidelity shows that relationships often struggle to recover after such betrayals, especially when the person who betrayed the trust doesn’t take full responsibility or act transparently.

The OP’s husband wasn’t just trying to patch things up, he was redefining the relationship without her consent, asking her to accept his affair as a new reality rather than acknowledging the damage he caused.

Polyamory requires clear agreements, and trying to turn a long‑standing affair into a polyamorous setup after betrayal doesn’t honor the emotional needs of the partner being left behind. It’s an effort to change the rules of the game in a way that benefits the betrayer but dismisses the betrayed partner’s emotional needs.

For the OP, choosing to file for divorce was an act of self‑preservation and boundary setting. The emotional damage done by this betrayal wasn’t something that could simply be fixed with more time or words, it required an understanding that emotional and psychological safety is worth more than a marriage bound together by broken promises.

Infidelity has long been recognized as one of the leading causes of divorce, and in this case, the OP’s decision to walk away was about reclaiming her sense of dignity and trust in herself and her future.

Here’s how people reacted to the post:

This group firmly believes that the husband’s repeated infidelity is unforgivable, urging the OP to finalize the divorce and move on for their own well-being

These commenters emphasized that the OP is justified in leaving, pointing out that the husband’s actions reflect a complete lack of respect for marriage vows and boundaries

These users echoed the sentiment that the OP should trust their own judgment, emphasizing the harmful impact of staying in a relationship built on lies and disrespect

This group criticized the husband’s behavior, particularly his push for polyamory without respect for the OP’s wishes

This commenter questioned the legitimacy of the church’s marriage counseling

What do you think? Was it right for her to leave, or should she have given him another chance? Share your thoughts below.